Renewable Energy II
The future of central grids – can crazy ideas make a new world?
by Saliem Fakir
Is it possible that we can envisage a new world in which the central grid gets outdated and a more diffused and dispersed system takes its place? Is this wishful thinking?
In a recent McKinsey report (May 2013) on disruptive technologies such an idea has been mooted but like McKinsey predicting the future can be a perilous thing – you can be hopelessly proven wrong or even be surprised by the radical change that even your own meagre predictions could not match.
If, our starting point is that there is a parallel process of a low carbon transition future from an initial high dependence on fossil fuels, to an intermediate phase of a mixed system, to total dominance by low carbon solutions and technologies than an emergent self-generating and autonomous grid system is possible.
Such a system should be flexible, resilient and adaptable to changing conditions and technology shifts. It is possible that distributed generation with enhanced grid capacity that involve both bulk transmission and mini-grids could be the future direction in which power supply will become the dominant feature of energy infrastructure in the next 20 years.
A silent revolution, that is already on the go within the existing system, could bring about a paradigm shift in the way we think of energy planning, especially for electricity and central grid models. These pathways already exist as more and more modular technologies in the form of renewables, fuel cells, gas turbines and other forms of modular power solutions begin to gain momentum and critical mass.
These have profound implications for current pathways that reflect a specific operating, planning and management model. Our view is that, if these do get to scale and become cost-effective, the central power system models will have little future as power generation will mostly come from modular systems that both feed the grid and use the grid to store energy. The idea of the grid will be flipped on its head: it will become a system for storage rather than transmission.
The dominance of a particular paradigm for energy planning dictates policy, the regulatory and institutional environment. Everything in its design, enactment and ways of investing lock the overall system along a particular pathway. These pathways are vulnerable to systemic risks and rapid shifts in disruptive innovations and technologies. Modular technologies and systems can be classified into different generations – first, second and third generation technologies and systems. The first is bulk and base-load systems that are inflexible, have long lead times and have slow response times to demand and supply fluctuations.
The first generation system is also centrally controlled and supplied. It is highly reliant on a strong tax base and central government spending.
Second generation systems include more intermittent sources with a mix of distributed generation but still dominated by bulk power generation investments such as large coal-fired power plants, pump-storage, nuclear and others.
And, finally, third generation sources will have predominance of distributed generation with less dependence on base-load solutions.
Third generation technologies are more likely to use multiple technologies integrated into one system – such as information technologies, remote sensing, bi-directional smart grids, hybrid energy stems that combine base-load and intermittent sources, and new types of technologies, with special composite materials, that can be controlled remotely or through self-adjustment and adaptation systems. Some of these technologies are already available on small scale or as demonstration projects. Third generation technologies are dominated by distributed generation, more responsive to supply and demand due to smart grid technologies and are self-adjusting as well as centrally managed.
The crucial thing is to understand how the enabling policy, regulatory and institutional environment operates in the current context, whether it’s design is structured in a manner that inadvertently predisposes the system for a particular model and approach to energy provision. The question is: can such a system be changed or reformed to allow a system to adapt to second and third generation options and technologies. In so doing allowing public and private choices to change flexibly to new types of pathways that allow the potential for systemic risk and collapse to be averted or alleviated through a more open and democratic and participatory energy system. Such enabling mechanisms for different pathways to evolve in co-existence will be the most optimal system design. With the proviso being that such a system prevents what a locked-in system can do, which is have the potential for inflexibility, increased or uncontrollable costs because of capital costs, currency volatility, large maintenance and fluctuating fuel costs.
A distributed generation model also reduces the burden on the state in terms of capital and investment allocation for bulk infrastructure. This burden can be shared if the energy system and regulatory environment allows for greater participation from users – who could also be buyers and sellers at the same time. All of this has to happen within a carbon constrained world, ensuring energy security that is affordable and driving new energy enterprises within the South African economy.
Mohamed Saliem Fakir
Senior Manager
Head of Living Planet Unit: WWF-SA
Read more about Saliem and his view on being a futurist.
Features Archive
- Green Energy
- Climate Change III
- Climate Change II
- Farming II
- Farming
- Banking VI
- Banking V
- Banking IV
- Politics III
- Politics II
- Politics
- AI Ethics IV
- AI Ethics III
- AI Ethics II
- AI Ethics
- Waste III
- Medicine
- Water IV
- Water III
- Creativity
- Solar Energy II
- Solar Energy
- Fashion
- Fashion II
- Humans IV
- Humans III
- Humans II
- Humans
- Money V
- Money IV
- Money III
- Money II
- Money
- Urban Futures II
- Urban Futures
- Ageing II
- Ageing
- Space IV
- Space III
- Space II
- Space
- Governments
- Metaverse IV
- Metaverse III
- Metaverse II
- Metaverse
- Technology III
- Technology IV
- Technology II
- Privacy III
- Privacy II
- Privacy
- Meat IV
- Meat III
- Meat II
- Meat
- Housing III
- Housing II
- Housing
- Retail
- Insurance
- Logistics II
- Logistics
- Mobile II
- Security III
- Security II
- Language II
- Tourism Post-Covid-19
- Entertainment Post-Covid-19 II
- Entertainment Post-Covid-19
- Cities Post-Covid-19
- Work Post-Covid-19 III
- Work Post-Covid-19 II
- Work Post-Covid-19
- Post-Covid-19 Economy II
- Post-Covid-19 Economy
- Education Post-Covid-19 II
- Education Post-Covid-19
- Post-Covid-19 V
- Post-Covid-19 IV
- Post-Covid-19 III
- Post-Covid-19 II
- Post-Covid-19
- Pandemics V
- Pandemics IV
- Pandemics III
- Pandemics II
- Pandemics
- Food II
- Food
- Futures V
- Futures IV
- Cars V
- Cars IV
- Cars III
- Cars II
- Cars
- Futures III
- Futures II
- Futures
- Education XI
- Education X
- Education IX
- Cities VI
- Cities V
- Cities IV
- AfriCities VIII
- AfriCities VII
- AfriCities VI
- AfriCities V
- AfriCities IV
- AfriCities III
- AfriCities II
- Youth II
- Migrants II
- Foresight IV
- Foresight III
- Higher Education VII
- Agriculture VII
- Work III
- Work/Women
- Cities III
- Carbon Tax
- Higher Education VI
- Higher Education V
- Higher Education IV
- Higher Education III
- Higher Education II
- Higher Education
- Banking III
- Banking II
- Banking
- Humanity VII
- Humanity VI
- Humanity V
- Humanity IV
- Humanity III
- Women V
- Digitalisation of Informal sector
- Islamic Economy
- Drones VII
- Drones VI
- Drones V
- Drones IV
- Drones III
- Drones II
- Drones
- Digital Health III
- Digital Health II
- Digital Health
- Transport IV
- Transport III
- Transport II
- Transport
- Infrastructure V
- Infrastructure IV
- Infrastructure III
- Crime V
- Crime IV
- Crime III
- Crime II
- Crime
- Agriculture VI
- Agriculture V
- Agriculture IV
- Agriculture III
- Agriculture II
- Women IV
- Women III
- Women II
- Women
- Humanity II
- Humanity
- Artificial Intelligence V
- Artificial Intelligence IV
- Artificial Intelligence III
- Universal Basic Income
- Alternative Economies V
- Alternative Economies IV
- Foresight II
- Alternative Economies III
- Additive manufacturing
- Artificial Intelligence II
- AI Risk, Ethics & Regulation
- Waste II
- Mining II
- African Futures IV
- Education VIII
- Justice
- Libraries III
- Libraries II
- Libraries
- Education VII
- Education VI
- Education V
- Green Energy II
- Financial Systems III
- Education IV
- Alternative Economies II
- Research
- Education III
- Artificial Intelligence
- Economic Integration II
- Health Inequity
- Invisible Economy
- Future Thinking
- Pan Africanism VII
- Infrastructure
- Financial Systems
- Sustainability III
- Sustainability II
- Alternative Economies
- Water II
- Mega Trends 2015, 2010s, 2100s?
- AfriCities
- Energy
- Sustainability
- Families
- Prisons II
- Prisons
- Work II
- Work
- Health II
- Pan-Africanism VI
- African Futures III
- African Futures II
- African Futures
- Economic Integration
- Climate Action III
- Manufacturing
- Green Economy
- Climate Action II
- Climate Action
- Foresight
- Ethnicity & Tribalism
- Pan-Africanism V
- Youth Policy II
- Gender Equality II
- Gender Equality
- Youth Policy
- Migrants
- Waste
- Pan-Africanism IV
- Pan-Africanism III - East Africa
- Pan-Africanism II
- Pan-Africanism
- Philanthropy
- Renewable Energy III
- Renewable Energy II
- Renewable Energy
- Informal Cities III
- Informal Cities II
- Informal Cities
- Human Development
- Security
- Global Engaged Citizens - Upskilling for Post Growth Futures, Together
- System Thinking - Systems thinking and courage
- Thrivability II - New Movements
- Thrivability - Bottom Line to Full Circle
- Youth Unemployment
- Food Insecurity II
- Food Insecurity
- Language
- Globesity
- Kenya II
- Kenya
- Mining
- Infrastructure II
- Women & Poverty II
- Women & Poverty
- Cities II
- Cities
- Innovation
- Climate Change
- Agriculture
- Books
- Youth
- Mobile
- Regional Integration IV
- Regional Integration III
- Regional Integration II
- Regional Integration
- Fresh Water
- Education II
- Health
- Education
- Leisure
- Urban Poor
- Economy
- Peace
- Women
- Technology
- Environmental
- Democracy
- The brief called for a blog
- Post-oil
- Game Changers